What I can't understand is why Nabisco a consumer company won't even comment. These are the best cookies bar noneI still haven't figured out why they stopped making these cookiesI live close to the nabisco plant (before they tore it down) and ask one person there why they quit making them and she could not answer me. There is a whole new generation that would love them. There is a Facebook on bring back the ideal cookie .someone said they talked to nabisco and they said they would consider it if enough people pushed for them back. Check out Little Debbie's substitute, Peanut Butter Crunch Bars: http://www.littledebbie.com/products/PBBars.asp I can't peel the chocolate off them like I did on the Ideals, but they're quite acceptable. Great site, was looking for Caravelle candy bars and then searched for the Ideal bars. These were a chocolate covered cookie shaped like a small candybar. These cookies popped into my head the other night, it's unfortunate that they are not made anymore. When Oreo began populating store shelves in 1912, it . So what? Mix together flour and potato starch flour; add to butter mixture and stir until combined. Little Debbie just doesn't get it done. Ideal Cookies were the BEST!!! !I wish Nabisco would bring them back!!!! And even if theyll always be the second banana compared to Oreo, they have a spot in the grocery store again. If you can believe it (and it's true) I actually went through shock treatment using Ideal bars as a food I should not eat (a loose weight gimmick in the 70's which is still used for smoking). I can recall in the early 70's playing football with the neighbood kids in the fall and after working up a good hunger pain we would walk down the block to the local A&P store and buy a package of Ideal cookies and eat them all. I would dearly love to give my dad a package of Ideal cookies. I would sign a petition to bring them back in a minute. I thought it was a heat issuenope. and spent my little savings on another package. nostalgia) things are "In" right now. We need to all call Nabisco! Taste most like the original Ideal than anything I've tried. Please, please consider bringing them back!! Addicted to Ideal cookies in the 70's . Nabisco are you listening? Something NEEDS to be done here!!! Still not quite the same.all time faveoriate cookie ever - even better than Mallowmars! http://kraftfoods.custhelp.com/cgi-bin/kraftfoods.cfg/php/enduser/ask.php? THE LITTLE DEBBIE ONES ARENT THAT BAD AT ALL BUT THEY ARE NOT IDEAL.THE ORIGINAL..SO CMON GANG EVERYONE GO TO NABISCO AND WRITE THEM A LETTER,TELL THEM ALL THE PEOPLE ON THIS SITE AND MAYBE THEY WILL MAKE THEM AGAIN , My favorite cookie above all was Ideal. My brother and I could eat a whole package of them in one sitting back when we were kids (ahhh, the good old days of a speedier metabolism!). Little Debbie makes a larger bar that are okay, but not from the same pure chocolate or peanut butter. I have thought of these cookies so many times over the years. Loved Ideals-The Very Best! Millions of other chocolate coated cookies survive shipping and storage - and I guess that most of us would still want them even if the chocolate was melted! Please, please, please bring them back!!! I also would like to see them brought back. I would eat the top off and then eat the peanut butter inside and then the bottom. I Goggled this cookie to see if anyone else remembered this sweet treat and boy was I surprised!! Please bring this cookie backit's been gone way too long!! Without a doubt we would find them. They are amazing! Oreo, which the company . I called Nabsico years ago to ask them to bring them back but no luck. There were air gaps between the various layers of the one cookie I ate so far. It's great to hear from consumers who are looking for our products because it lets us know how much you enjoy them. It's a shame they don't listen to the loyal consumers (as this blog demonstrates)and make that investment into bringing back such a popular item. Bring em back! Nabisco, please bring them back!!! My husband raves about Ideal cookies. I have found a cookie bar made by Little Debbie snacks, called peanut butter crunch bars. :}. If you want a good substitute, though remember that it's merely a substitute, try the Trader Joe's Chocolate-covered Peanut Butter Pretzels. The truth was a bit more complicated, however. Then, I'd eat the ends of each bar first. OfficeWorld.com has over 100K business products in-stock, up to 80% savings, industry-leading service, FREE 1- to 2-day delivery over $49*! I immediatly thought about Ideal cookies for the first time in many years, looked on Google and found this site. I agree that they were the best store-bought cookies ever. Please, Nabiscobring them back. We put the lil debbie's the freezer (as close as you can get, but not the same) and everytime the grand kids here me say not like an Ideal!! I wrestled with my weight as a kid in the late 70's, yet every once in a while my mom would secretly buy a box of these rich logs of dark chocolately goodness, if only to show her undying love for me, her only begotten son. Ideals were what I thought of! Maybe if everyone emails Nabisco, they'll bring our favorite cookie back. I've thought about them for years and could not understand why they are no longer available, OMG!!!!!!!!!! the real reason is that it was the perfect cookie. It's just barely enough for the 2 pie crusts I needed to make this morning, where it used to be plenty with leftovers. Ideal cookies were my favorite, too. I am so glad I found this site. To this day 30 years later we agree there was not a better cookie ever after they stopped making them. I can pass up any other store bought cookie but not these. My sisters and I loved them and ordering GS Tagalongs reminds us every year that they've disappeared. Please bring them back. Lets all write or e-mail Nabisco. Nabisco has seen this website; it just doesn't care. All the comments on this page are only the tip of the iceberg. I was sitting in bed and the name just came back to me so I Googled "Ideal"! I would love to see these cookies back in the grocery store, or even available through online ordering. I remember these well, I too have discussed with Nabisco about getting these back on the shelf,but no I have to make do with my home made peanutbutter chocolate bars pretty good but not an Ideal bar. My best guess why Nabisco quit making them is that they were too expensive to produce; in order to maintain the high quality of the product the retail cost would be unrealistic. I thought I was the only one who really missed these cookies! It was the best store bought. It was child abuse I tell ya. They were not made in the summer because they would melt. OK, so what WAS it about the Ideal bars? Please we need to unite and get Nabisco to bring the Ideal bar cookie back. Little Debbie,PB Twix etc. Go to this page and leave them a request to BRING BACK IDEAL COOKIE BARS!!! Sometimes we used them as scoops with vanilla or new york ice cream. I'm surprised they quit making them, with all the fans they evidently have out there. One of the few foods I would eat in the middle of the night. Nabisco Giggles cookies were introduced in the 1980s, and they were only sold for about a decade. I love that there are so many Ideal bar addicts out there. I loved IDEAL bars!! No other cookie compares. Ok folks, you can duplicate the taste of these Ideal cookies. They might look up that stats every year and laugh but did they stop to think there is a new generation of peanut butter cookie lovers out there. Ideal bars are by far the best cookie of my childhood. I loved them. Finally I returned home with the Ideal cookies after eating my final bite so that the perfect amout was found by my Mom. I just got finished eating Reese's Sticks that I had gotten from the fridge and I thought of the Ideal cookies!! I won't have to SHARE!! She had the idea of looking for them online. When we'd visit Grandma and Grandpa, they'd open Ideal Bars after dinner, and we'd consume the whole package while watching TV. Like Atlas Obscura and get our latest and greatest stories in your Facebook feed. They were the Best Only draw back was they melted so easily. Please, Please, meet public demand and produce them again. 8 Discontinued Oreo Flavors | Mental Floss You can find alot of copycat recipes for these cookies if you google "ideal nabisco cookie bars". You also need to bring back the Famous Cookie Assortment. Always will be!! Bring 'em back Nabisco it's time!!! Every year for Christmas my parents would buy me a lot of them for my stocking. They were my absolute fav cookie and I can almost taste one! My husband and I lived in the mountains befor they had cable, so we would listen to the stereo and have Ideal cookies and Milk two or three times a week! After a few seconds the insides would be all smooshy. OMG!!!!! Nabisco, You MUST bring these Back. Fact check: Oreos maker Nabisco is not sending US jobs to Mexico As a matter of fact,they were terrible. I would weigh 500 lbs more than I do now if they didn't, and willing to pay alot per bag so I'd be broke. Go figure! I recall that from late 60's to late 70's my mom would buy the cheap "kiddie" cookies for us, and Ideal Peanut Butter Bars for herself, which she would keep in the fridge. If they ever do, there is going to be mass hysteria and total chaos around the world!! I guess it was supposedly the heat that they stopped manufacturing these cookies. Or give it to the Girl Scouys. "Squeaky wheel gets the IDEAL" Put this in your Header to Nabisco. They were very good/, So there's no way to get these anymore then? See. . I am so dissapointed I can't get these for him. They were a very high quality cookie. I too remember these as a kid - we kept them in the fridgeI was thinking about them today which brought me to this page. Last time I had these was 4/17/80, my birthday, and I'm still dreaming about them 30 years later bring em back! Oh PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE bring these cookies back. I was thinking of a nice surprise that I could get my two sisters who will soon be turning 50. We would eat them all in one weekend!! These Discontinued Snacks Will Make You Nostalgic - Business Insider I grew up on them as treats and have been looking for them for YEARS!!!!!!! I look for IDEAL cookies every time I am at the grocery store hoping to see that Nabisco has reintroduced them. I'll send a link to my sister. What can we do to have Nabisco make these cookies again? Please Nabisco, Ideal or whomever owns the recipebring them back! Please Nabisco bring back the Ideal cookie, Check this out. I still hunt for them from time to time. Love them and really wish they would bring them back the SAME as the were! the time is ripe for bringing back some treasured tastes of the old days! It's a crime! Oreo was one of three cookies introduced by Nabisco on April 2, 1912, with the other twothe Mother Goose biscuit and the Veronese biscuitnow lost to history. PLEASE BRING THESE BACK, NABISCO!!! They were better than the Oreo with peanut butter in the middle, and that is saying a lot because I love those Oreos. Still, it is the Oreo that has become the icon.. Follow us on social media to add even more wonder to your day. Do your part to make this happenPLEASE!!! I'm on a mission now!!! I do not know why Nabisco do not hear the voices crying. Please bring them back! IT IS A SHAME THAT NABISCO WILL NOT MAKE THE COOKIES AND SELL THEM ONLINEHINT HINT NABISCO. Really, we would all buy them if they would just bring them back, I would love one right now!!! jjcardella@hotmail.com. Intended to imply hydrogen and oxygenthe two chemicals that make up waterthe result has a more clinical, less roll-off-the-tongue convention to it, and instead evokes hydrogen peroxide, a chemical you probably dont want to drink. Nabisco, if you do bring them back, KEEP THE RECIPE EXACTLY THE SAME!!! You can't find anything that even comes close to the taste. They will always pull a box out right before we were leaving. These cookies were highly addictive! My husband is addicted to these cookies.wanted to give them to him for Valentine's Day and thought perhaps, like the old candies (I was able to get through another distributer), that I could find someone who still made these. Please, someone foreward all these requests to Nabisco. Another brand recently introduced a snack that looks just like Ideal Cookies but not even close to the original taste. Oh how I miss that Ideal cookie! Nabisco cannot continue implying that there is not enough demand for the Ideal cookie. Anyway, I wish they would bring them back, That would make the perfect Mothers Day present:), I'm glad it wasn't my imaginationI have had dreams of those fantastic cookie bars! I think the best advise we read was to write to Nabisco. Maybe I will email Keebler and encourage them to check out this site - for sure there's a demand - so how 'bout they provide the supply - :). I agree - best cookie ever! Absolutly loved 'em and as kids growing up in the 70's fought over them. There was a whole ritual to my after-school consumption of this sweetest of sins: We would take them out of the 'fridge (I thought that mom would hide them in there, but now I understand it was because of the low melting point of the chocolate). Peanut butter, chocolate and that delicious chocolate. Only it turned out, four years later, to also be a game-changer for Nabiscos Oreo. In the 1970s and 80s, when the guards stepped away, the pots and flames came out. Yes, we loved the chocolate-peanut butter delights that melted deliciously on our fingers enough to sit through Lawrence Welk! I JUST CAME FROM THE STORE AND STILL LOOK IN THE COOKIE ISLE JUST HOPING NABISCO WOULD BRING THEM BACK. Please bring them back, Nabisco! Ya Gotta bring EM back they are the true IDEAL snack of all time!!! I would, I loved them. Nabisco reportedly discontinued the cookies because they often broke in the packaging and were too expensive to produce. I havent had an Ideal cookie in about 45 years but they are still my favorite cookie- bar none. No purchase necessary. YOU CANNOT HAVE THIS MANY PEOPLE WANTING THIS COOKIE AND IGNORE THEM. Pleeeeease bring them back! http://nabiscoworld.custhelp.com/app/contact. I cannot beleive that the powers that be at "Nabisco" are not aware of the number of people that want these cookies back at any cost. Nothing made today compares! I have missed these cookies and have tried with much disappointment to find a replacementPlease, Nabisco, bring them back! Mom finally had to restrict us to 1 each otherwise they never lasted more than an hour after getting them home. Good times. We would all definitely be willing to spend our hard earned money on a package of those awesome ideal bars! Nabisco if you arent going to bring back the Ideal Cookie, then sell the Cookie recipe and rights to some company that will. There's nothing left. Timmy D PGH WE will prevail. !my mom says she LOVED them! I think maybe Nabisco, but not real sure. After dinner, I couldn't eat much, but I even got to share some more Ideal cookies with my Mom and this is where my life of food-crime began. I would do almost anything for a package of Ideal cookies. Very rich & creamy: You needed a tall glass of ice cold milk to offset the decadence of this confection. Wow, I went online looking for Count Chocula and I found this great support group for fans of the greatest cookie ever! Heaven on earth! Family-run for more than a century, this pizzeria makes a unique mustard pie. E-mail your local news station with this link. I was telling some co-workers about Ideal cookies the other day and one of them googled the name. Then she dunked the whole thing in melted semi-sweet chocolate chips. Please Nabisco bring back these cookies. I love Ideal cookies!!! I used to love Ideal Bars: there was a certain salty sweet inside "crunch", and the way the outside chocolate used to melt, so you had to eat it faster, especially in the summer! I am going to keep trying and contacting them. My favorite cookie ever! Sounds like this cookie has a "Cult" followingha! I loved these cookies. Ideal cookie bars were the BEST. Press gently with palm of hand to flatten slightly. I loved those cookies. I also feel the same way about the old Hershey 'Bar None' candy bar, which only lasted a short timeduring the 1990's. Every trip down the cookie isle, I scan every shelf looking for them. I remember them not being available in the summer months and assume this was because the chocolate would melt. My sister and I were reminiscing and wishing they were still around. He was amazed that I knew what he was asking. I used to look forward to our Sunday visits to my grandparents. I talk about them and people have no idea what I am talking about. I wish I could get through to Kraft/Nabisco! I might even vote for Newt Gingrich if he promised to bring our declicious little ideal bars backwell, I'm not sure if I'd do that, but I would consider it. If anyone is lucky enough to live somewhere close to a Trader Joe's, then you need to go and buy their Chocolate Covered Peanut Butter Pretzels!! I would love for my grandchildren to experience the best taste I have EVER tasted in my lifetime! I actually had someone get mad at me for introducing them to those addictive cookies. soooooooo are they coming back, i'm still needing them!!!!!! I agree with everybody on this page. I'm with you guys; Scott, Jim, Jan, et,al My most treasured memories of the seventies include that cookie/bar. In the 80's, I believe, Ideal just didn't sell that well, and they were discontinued; I have a feeling that as the price crept higher and higher, many of the brands that were never featured were ignored. My sister used to buy them and hide them under her bed and i would steal them. #SnackCation. They were great. I also love these cookies. My family still brings up these delicious cookies and wonders why Nabisco doesn't make them anymore It's Time to write Nabisco, Best cookie ever! I would give up every store-bought cookie---sorry Pepperidge Milanos---for one Ideal Bar! Well do you know I went right back up to that shelf and proceded to eat the rest of them. Those Ideal bars were so great, maybe the top notch ingredients didn't leave them enough profit. They were wonderful. This is a dark time in cookie history, one Hydrox partisan, Gary Nadeau, wrote, according to the Wall Street Journal. Perhaps Nabisco has a deal with Reeses that they will not compeet! When I first got married I would buy them from the grocery store (back in 1982) and my husband and I would tag team these cookies until there was an empty package left in the cabinet. I'll bet Elvis did too! They were so wonderful!! When I was in my 20s and did not have to worry about weight or health, I would consume and ENTIRE box all by myself during an evening with glasses of milk. Brand history. This was a big deal for him since he never packed his own lunch. I was told way back in the 70's also that they quit making them during the warm months.. and then never started making them again one year. Little Debbies just don't work for me. I can't go in to the cookie isle without looking for them. My dad used to get at least to boxes of these one for himself and another for the kids. I, TOO, LOVED Ideal Bars growing up and into adulthood. I would love to have them again. I do all the shopping! I miss them!! I have been looking for these cookies for years now! The Rise, Fall, and Return of Hydrox Cookies, the Proto-Oreo But while Oreo ascended to become something of a cultural touchstone, Hydrox retained its partisans, in part also because the slightly-more-bitter cookie was also kosher. Please bring them back! Discontinuing them to develop a more profitable product may have made some punk executive a bonus but in doing so the Nabisco brand was greatly diminished. i.ve been looking for those ideal bars everywhere.when i was younger i used to babysit i took my money and go to the store and buey ideal bars and eat the whole package they were so good.i wish they would bring them back!!!!!!!!!! Someone else posted a comment mentioning how they thought that they must not be going crazy, they really did exist. they really left an impression on me. They were even better cold. Ooops, maybe the Yoohoos I stole from Uncle Charlie's sandwich shop was first?!?!?! Nothing else compares. Cannot understand why Nabisco will not bring them back. Once I nearly cut off my finger trying to cut one from the end that had stuck to the others. Are there any other theories out there? They sent some coupons to me in the mail and stated they would report my request. He was going on about what happened to "his" peanut butter bars. We are sisters who grew up in California in the 60's and 70's and were TOTALLY addicted to the Ideal cookie bar!!! The recipe I normally use as the closest approach to the original Brown Edge Wafer that Nabisco used to make is this one from Cookie Madness, based on a recipe from the potato flour packaging. In the past 10 years or so I have not found them and about 2009 time frame I asked Nabisco what happened and they said that they stopped making them totally. At the end of their email form, they give a phone number.